Keep pruning assumptions and deferred choices
Record the assumptions behind a search exclusion and retain the candidate so it can be reopened when evidence or prerequisites change.
These examples and illustrative results are independently authored teaching materials, not measured model results.
Use case
Cost comparison deferred B using a profile from prompt v1 and another runtime setting. Prompt v2 may change token texture, while B has no current measurement. An unfavorable projection is not a permanent verdict.
Mechanism
Record candidate, task/prompt identity, measured profile, projection and pruning assumptions. Mismatched evidence means deferred, not deleted. Prompt/config/calibration changes trigger reevaluation under matched conditions and an authorized bounded probe. Preserve registered quality/cost standards rather than guarantee optimum from uncalibrated ordering.
Bad example
Permanently delete B from a mismatched old projection, retain it after v2 and claim globally minimum cost.
Good example
Keep B deferred with the v1/setting/profile mismatch. After v2, inspect quality/cost prerequisites and propose a bounded matched-condition probe within authorized evaluation. Unmeasured current cost stays unknown; do not claim B necessarily expensive or global optimum. Record actual reopening/retention/exclusion evidence.
Why the change matters
Contextual estimates become false timeless rules when their premises disappear. Retained assumptions/candidates make changed conditions reviewable without promising a global winner.
Observable expectation
An illustrative table identifies deferred B, old profile and reopening on v2/setting changes; current cost is unknown. New judgments cite matched conditions, not priors or a lucky single result.
Keep candidates/quality gates visible. No paid evaluation is performed.
Limits
Projection error, quality variation and pruning assumptions matter. Frozen model/effort monotonicity, error factors/prices are not universal current laws. Define budget/permission and distinguish guesses from measurements.
Sources and evidence
- anthropics/skills · Explicit monotonicity and conservative screen
File at this version8a1541c4a3ff - anthropics/skills · Noisy promotion and revisitable deferral
File at this version8a1541c4a3ff - anthropics/skills · Earlier verdict expires after context change
File at this version8a1541c4a3ff